30 Days Is Not Enough: Limited Treatment Is Costing Lives

By MaryBeth Cichocki 01/02/17

To be successful in this war against opioid addiction, we must change our mindset. Long-term addiction treatment should be an affordable option.

MaryBeth Cichocki Advocates Long Term Addiction Treatment

I can tell you from my personal experience as both a NICU nurse and the mother of a man who suffered from substance use disorder that if addiction was treated comprehensively from the first admission, both lives and money would be saved. 

Addiction is the only chronic, treatable disease that is limited in receiving long-term life-saving treatment. I referred to the years during my son's battle as the revolving doors of recovery. Rather than allowing Matt to remain in treatment until he was strong enough to remain clean he was forced to leave before he was ready, setting him up for a relapse and another too-short admission either to the same facility or whichever one had an available bed. Matt was given 30 days per year. Matt is dead. I ask you, what other chronic disease gets this limited treatment? Where is the parity when it comes to substance use disorder?  

I witnessed the same discrimination when speaking to the mothers whose infants became my patients in the NICU—infants born dependent. These mothers reached out for treatment prior to becoming pregnant or early in their pregnancies only to becoming members of the revolving door club. The insurance companies refused to allow these mothers to stay in treatment long enough to stay clean. Rather than spending the money helping these mothers to get and stay clean, Medicaid pays out thousands of dollars per year in hospital stays for drug-dependent infants.  

According to the AMA, in 2009 hospital care for an NAS infant cost $53,000. With the rising cost of healthcare, that cost has likely doubled in 2016. At any point in time my NICU received up to 14 NAS babies. Many of these infants required months of care. Imagine the money Medicaid would save if those mothers were treated properly and those infants were born healthy.

Medicaid also pays for methadone maintenance treatment during the pregnancy, keeping these mothers dependent on yet another highly addictive, dangerous drug. Some of these mothers remain on methadone for months after delivery as weaning this drug is a process and most detox facilities deny admission to anyone on medication-assisted treatment. Just continuing to spend money when the initial investment into treatment would have saved so much more. 

Let's look at the effect of addiction on the foster care system. This system is already oversaturated with children in need of a safe home. Some addicted parents lose custody of their children due to their disease and behavior associated with the lifestyle. These children are ripped away from the parents they love and either placed with another family member or given to total strangers.

Imagine the emotional impact on these innocent victims of addiction. Yet, this is the nationwide solution for children of addiction. Money is now spent on paying strangers in this foster care system. Why not spend that money toward rehabilitation of the parent? Why not spend the money on long-term comprehensive treatment and work toward reuniting families? It would be more cost-effective for the insurance industry and psychologically safer for the child. 

Let's explore another aspect of addiction and cost—unemployment. Imagine the impact on this overburdened system if the insurance industry covered longer term in-patient treatment. Those suffering from substance use disorder would have the time to recover and return to being a productive member of the workforce. Contributing to the system instead of taking from it.  

Drug-related crime would also decrease. According to NADCP, approximately 60% of arrested individuals tested positive for an illicit drug at arrest. Imagine the impact on the crime rate if those who were living with addiction were treated comprehensively. Investing funds into drug courts rather than incarceration. This system provides comprehensive treatment and close supervision keeping offenders in treatment long enough to get them well. 

To be successful in this war against opioid addiction, we must change our mindset. We must acknowledge that 30-day treatment programs are failing. We continue to lose 129 people daily nationwide to this deadly epidemic.

We must also acknowledge the medical research that has proven substance use disorder to be a brain disease. Understanding that at minimum those suffering from this disease must receive at least 90 days in treatment followed by months of extended follow up. Allowing a transition from a safe clinical setting to a partial outpatient setting which includes the outside recovery community and family support. 

According to the National Institute of Drug Abuse (NIDA), "The threshold of significant improvement is reached at about three months into treatment, however treatment that lasts longer shows better results." A lot of addicts suffer from more than just drug addiction. Many issues such as mental and physical trauma, anxiety, depression and similar co-existing disorders go hand-in-hand with addiction.  

Limiting in-patient treatment sets those suffering from this brain disease up for continuous failure and possibly death. Research has shown that successful recovery takes place over time. The brain has changed due to long-term damage from substance abuse. Depending on the drugs used and the duration of the addiction, healing could take approximately three months to one year

The brain must reset itself, thought processes must return to a normal, healthy state. This doesn't happen in the current 30-day model of treatment. During the initial 10-14 days, detox and stabilization are taking place. My son was just beginning to feel human again after the first two weeks in treatment. Sadly, his insurance provider refused to cover additional days and he quickly relapsed.  

In my opinion, until the insurance industry recognizes substance use disorder as a chronic, treatable brain disease, we will continue to lose our loved ones to this mistreated, misunderstood disease. This industry must take responsibility for their part in the epidemic we face today. Addiction is the only chronic, treatable disease that is limited in receiving life-saving treatment.

In all my years of nursing I've never heard of a cancer patient or infant born suffering from withdrawal be informed that they've reached a limit on treatment days. Goodbye and good luck. This is exactly what I experienced with my son, Matt. He was bounced around like a ping pong ball. Never given long enough in treatment to give him a fighting chance at recovery. 

The solution to saving lives is simple. It requires the insurance industry to recognize parity, allowing long-term treatment to be available for those suffering from substance use disorder. Those making decisions regarding treatment coverage must attend mandatory education in the disease of addiction. Education leads to understanding. Understanding leads to changing the model that continues to kill our loved ones. Saving lives taking precedent over saving money. Making recovery not just a possibility but a reality. 

Please read our comment policy. - The Fix
MaryBeth Cichocki.jpg

MaryBeth Cichocki is a registered nurse living in the state of Delaware. She lost her son, Matt, to an overdose of prescription drugs on January 3, 2017. Unable to return to the world of taking care of critically ill babies, she now devotes her time to raising awareness of the dangers of these drugs. She writes a blog called mothersheartbreak.com telling the story of her battle during her son's addiction. She remains in touch with lawmakers in Florida, where her son lost his life, pushing for regulation of sober living homes. She plans to begin speaking through different organizations, educating the public about the dangers of unregulated pain management clinics. Her dream is to one day have her blog published and set up a scholarship fund in memory of Matt to provide adult addicts the financial means to remain in long-term rehabilitation until they are both physically and mentally ready to return to a productive life. You can follow MaryBeth on Twitter.